Claws Seafood Market

Located in the heart of West Sayville, Claws Seafood Market is a must-visit destination for anyone craving fresh, high-quality seafood paired with a laid-back, local vibe. Serving both as a seafood market and a fish and chips takeaway, this charming mom-and-pop establishment offers an authentic taste of the coast, right on Montauk Highway.

Claws Seafood Market stands out for its exceptional selection of fresh seafood, brought directly to customers in a warm, inviting setting where casual attire and relaxed attitudes are welcomed with open arms. Whether you're stopping by for a quick takeaway or opting to dine in, the atmosphere is refreshingly unpretentious—Julie Corwin perfectly captures this by highlighting how guests can show up in their riding or barn clothes without any fuss.

The menu, though simple, boasts deeply satisfying flavors and generous portions. Fans rave about the lobster rolls, described by Daniel Tusso as both "delicious and filling," a true testament to the quality and heartiness of the offerings. The shrimp Po Boys also earn high marks; while not exactly a New Orleans original, Mark Powell’s appreciation underscores the kitchen's skill at crafting bold, comforting sandwiches that hit the spot. For those who enjoy shellfish, the mussels during the seafood festival have been a standout, making it a great spot to return to in the summer months.

Beyond the classics, Claws impresses with standout sides like their sweet potato fries, called “blow me out of the water” by Julie, and surprisingly excellent hush puppies, which Kimberly Sabat describes as “better than expected” and generously portioned. The soups, such as their lobster bisque, have garnered mixed but loving feedback—ample and comforting, even if the bisque leans a little heavy on the wine. It’s the kind of dish that warms you on a chilly day, conjuring the cozy charm of this intimate spot. Moreover, the discovery of the Blood Orange Sicilian Soda adds a refreshing twist that guests find irresistible.

Service at Claws Seafood Market is another highlight, noted for its friendly, fast, and distinctly local vibe. Kimberly appreciates the smiles and warmth from the team, making the entire experience feel personal and genuine. The clean facility and reasonable prices add value, solidifying Claws as a community favorite that’s as accessible as it is delicious.

In summary, Claws Seafood Market offers a delightful seafood experience rooted in authenticity and local pride. From fresh catches to expertly crafted sides and an earnest dedication to customer service, it’s a true hidden gem on Montauk Highway that seafood lovers and casual diners alike will find themselves returning to time and again.